1. Home
  2. Categories
  3. Support
  4. Conan remove fails with -p filter on ProGet remote (works with dry-run)

Welcome to the Inedo Forums! Check out the Forums Guide for help getting started.

If you are experiencing any issues with the forum software, please visit the Contact Form on our website and let us know!

Conan remove fails with -p filter on ProGet remote (works with dry-run)

  • M

    There seems to be an issue with ProGet's Conan V2, where the conan remove command fails when using the -p profile filter.

    example:
    conan remove freetype/2.13.2:* -p os=Linux -r=ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2 --dry-run -c

    gives:

    Remove summary: ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2 freetype/2.13.2#012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2: Removed binaries: ['43faaf581cf6a121854a451651cf2ff235f19f7c', 'd87280ec3b4af24f27d50d5e0df28450bce31aea', 'e0458180222f4e39fcff2bfa680bfa6468ca7198']

    Whereas the non dry-run:

    conan remove freetype/2.13.2:* -p os=Linux -r=ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2 -c

    gives us:

    ERROR: expected revision after package id. [Remote: ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2]

    We reached out to the Conan team, where they tested and confirmed it should be working fine from their end, see thread: https://github.com/conan-io/conan/issues/18553

    Could you investigate and confirm if this is a known limitation or bug?

    Thanks!

    0 stevedennis 1 Reply
    Log in to reply
     
  • stevedennis
    inedo-engineer

    Hi @mmaharjan_0067,

    I think we can call this a "known limitation" now that you've discovered it ;)

    It's a bit tricky to set up a conan debug/testing environment, so to advance this further instead of putting off another few days.... do you mind trying to run the command with --verbose and share the output? How about without the -p command?

    I'm just trying to see what URLs the conan client is trying to call, and make a guess for how we can address it.

    Thanks,
    Steve

    1 M 1 Reply
  • M

    Hi @stevedennis,

    Running conan remove freetype/2.13.2:* -r=ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2 -c -vvv we get:

    HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v1/ping
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/search
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/0b9eabda69d299e0c26d9c8317ddd1621897aa07/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/2bc290d37f8ba2643b676474fd64176f8b8de109/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/2c78a73f698fca3c09a1748a63533228464ad95e/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/330feb85e7c7f73d79b8dcd7d66b0dfcb300d055/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/43faaf581cf6a121854a451651cf2ff235f19f7c/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/56ab506ea707052770ee3fe2c74d207e03eb913b/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/5a368093f9a03ee939b6113024e4e050e0b8ab85/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/824d26f8edc07cf9d12c6e3a7bcc11c9ce0005e9/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/8465556e8df301d7ad4d45939533bd110dc4fc9f/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/871fc4926cbe6ce3b4b4042931c0b98e1ed1553c/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/8fab62d98251e0c58e525e58a5ddbc9d03762335/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/bab1ebe447bc8c2837e705948cb15e08d1d7c49f/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/c47e9d1a66bc77b47abc78dfebcae9d0b554d34b/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/d87280ec3b4af24f27d50d5e0df28450bce31aea/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/e0458180222f4e39fcff2bfa680bfa6468ca7198/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/users/check_credentials
HttpRequest: delete: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/0b9eabda69d299e0c26d9c8317ddd1621897aa07/revisions/5af71bb11e7691ed2a1d95bf2156b5f8

    With the -p ie. conan remove freetype/2.13.2:* -p os=Linux -r=ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2 -c -vvv we get:

    HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v1/ping
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/search
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/43faaf581cf6a121854a451651cf2ff235f19f7c/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/d87280ec3b4af24f27d50d5e0df28450bce31aea/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/e0458180222f4e39fcff2bfa680bfa6468ca7198/revisions
HttpRequest: get: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/users/check_credentials
HttpRequest: delete: https://proget.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/conan/ccdc-3rdparty-conan/v2/conans/freetype/2.13.2/_/_/revisions/012f2e384087877914dbac626c3978e2/packages/43faaf581cf6a121854a451651cf2ff235f19f7c/revisions/b698aa74ca56cfc1edeca40d1939a310

    In both cases we get the same error:

    Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/cli/cli.py", line 193, in run
    command.run(self._conan_api, args[0][1:])
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/cli/command.py", line 179, in run
    info = self._method(conan_api, parser, *args)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/cli/commands/remove.py", line 119, in remove
    conan_api.remove.package(pref, remote=remote)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/api/subapi/remove.py", line 50, in package
    app.remote_manager.remove_packages([pref], remote)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/internal/rest/remote_manager.py", line 210, in remove_packages
    return self._call_remote(remote, "remove_packages", prefs)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/internal/rest/remote_manager.py", line 269, in _call_remote
    return self._auth_manager.call_rest_api_method(remote, method, *args, **kwargs)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/internal/rest/auth_manager.py", line 60, in call_rest_api_method
    ret = getattr(rest_client, method_name)(*args, **kwargs)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/internal/rest/rest_client.py", line 81, in remove_packages
    return self._get_api().remove_packages(prefs)
  File "/mnt/f/conan2/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/conan/internal/rest/rest_client_v2.py", line 385, in remove_packages
    raise get_exception_from_error(response.status_code)(response.text)
conan.internal.errors.RequestErrorException: expected revision after package id. [Remote: ccdc-3rdparty-conan-2]
    0 stevedennis 1 Reply
  • stevedennis
    inedo-engineer

    @mmaharjan_0067 thanks for sharing that

    I misunderstood the remove command -- I didn't realize that was deleting from the feed, and just assumed it was removing from the local project or something.

    I don't see any code for DELETE in the feed, so we would have to add that. No idea how easy that is going to be, but we'll try doing it at same time with the UI improvements. You can track via PG-3035.

    Thanks,
    steve

    1 M 1 Reply
  • M

    @stevedennis

    By default the command operate in the local cache, but with the -r=remote argument it removes artifacts from the server.
    Ref: https://docs.conan.io/2/reference/commands/remove.html

    0
Log in to reply
 
Inedo Website Home • Support Home • Code of Conduct • Forums Guide • Documentation