Call to $CredentialProperty fails with "not configured to allow access to encrypted values" when it is

[brandon_owensby_2976]

I have code that is trying to get Token using $CredentialProperty and it says it fails with "not configured to allow access to encrypted values" but this doesn't appear to be the case. First here is the line of code in question:

This is executed where $BuildMasterApiKeyName = "global::BuildMaster"

$CredentialProperty($BuildMasterApiKeyName, Token);

The execution log shows the error: The specified credential property "Token" is marked as encrypted and the "global::BuildMaster" credential is not configured to allow access to encrypted values.

Here is a screenshot showing that property as checked:

Thank you,
Brandon